Monday, December 17, 2012

Missing the Elephant in the Room


“We cast down imaginations and every high thing that exalts itself against God and bring every thought captive to the obedience of Christ.”                   (2 Corinthians 10:5 KJV)

Because world-views lead to their own respective consequences, it is not sufficient for Christians to season our culture by the adding of a bit of Christian flavor.  For the sake of the preservation of our society, we are in dire need of a total overhaul of our vision of what it means to be human.  Every person holds a world-view of sorts, although people don’t often reflect deeply on the particulars.  A world-view is, according to the BING definition, “a view of all life: a comprehensive and usually personal conception or view of humanity, the world, or life.”

O. Hobart Mowrer, one-time president of the American Psychiatric Association, had such an overhaul (an intensely personal one) of his own world-view.  As an adherent of Freud’s (a noted psychiatrist) dismissive views on guilt, Mowrer early on argued that every expression of personal guilt was a harmful pathological sickness which demanded release by means of psychoanalysis.  Yet when he himself was admitted to a mental institution following on his own breakdown, he came to recognize that confession (as opposed to denial) of his own guilt was precisely the path to his own healing.  So after his release he was dismayed to discover that churches were also dismissing the concepts of sin and guilt along the lines of Freud.  However, other leaders from the field of psychology have expressed the same observations as Dr. Mowrer about the necessary connection between confession of guilt (sin) and personal healing, including M. Scott Peck, Karl Menninger, and Paul Pruyser.

At the risk of oversimplification, it seems necessary to state that our culture is experiencing the clash of two major world-views.  The dominant one being promoted in the public arena, the secular view, dismisses such notions as transcendent purpose, values, morality, free-will, and accounttability.  The second, Christian, world-view holds that under God our Maker, there is an over-arching purpose to life, that human beings have innate value (not merely a utilitarian one), that we are not mere machines but have a soul and consequently free-will, that there is a solid foundation for morality, and that we will all be held accountable to God who will judge the entire world according to His righteousness.

Three days of reflection after the tragic cold-blooded murder of 27 innocent people, including 20 defenseless little children at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut raises a multitude of questions as to how this could have happened.  One leading voice is stating that this senseless violence must stop once and for all.  Certainly we can sympathize with his frustration.  But his statement is an expression arising from his own world-view.  God does have an answer, but His answer is connected to the dealing with human guilt once and for all by the death of His Son on the cross, and the working of the Holy Spirit within the lives of redeemed sinners.  Apart from God’s answer human nature has not a ghost of a chance of changing.

Discussions regarding the shooter’s actual culpability are typically being framed in light of his mental and family history.  Questions are being asked for the purpose of understanding his motives.  But if sin is real, that is the one factor that does defy the rational.  Sin is the moral error of raising one’s sense of self-importance above all others, and most especially above God.  To neglect our misuse of personal freedom and responsibility, to cloud matters of right and wrong, and to brush aside the universal human tendency to act against our own consciences (including the cold-blooded and calculating shooter), by instead proposing a mechanistic answer alone, completely misses a fundamental clue about the evil we all experience in the world.  I am not pleading that we neglect mental illness in favor of spiritual realities.  We ought to give serious attention to both.  Christians fully affirm that there is a material aspect of our being.  But we argue that under God we are so much more than that.

We need religious revival today.  By “religious,” Christians mean regaining the vision that all of life makes sense only when we are in right relationship with the God who made the heavens and the earth at the beginning of time, who sent His Son Jesus Christ for our redemption from sin in the fullness of time, and who invites us to live in union with Him in the present time.  Every aspect of our lives (heart, soul, strength, and mind) is transformed by our connection to God, alone.  To neglect this vision in place of the prevailing, failing mechanistic view of life is tantamount to missing the gigantic elephant in the room.  

No comments:

Post a Comment